Restricting the review to this recent window ensures the findings reflect current assessment practices across higher education. Finally, data relevant to each research question were extracted and systematically coded. First, study parameters were defined based on the research questions, including publication timeframe, publication type, and https://aicurated.com/ai-applications/new-hope-soleburys-ai-plan-starts-with-how-students-learn/ topical relevance. Therefore, the purpose of this systematic review is to answer the call from scholars (viz., Gundu, 2024; Lee & Moore, 2024; Xia et al., 2024) to further examine assessment practices in HE in the GenAI milieu. Lee and Moore (2024) conducted a systematic review of GenAI for automated feedback in HE, identifying the growing use of GenAI-generated feedback, particularly within writing-related contexts.
- While AI tools offer the potential for improved outcomes, they also present risks to the authenticity of assessments, potentially undermining academic integrity.
- These tools allow students to automatically generate essays, reports, and coding solutions, increasing the risk of plagiarism and contract cheating 55, 56, 79,80,81.
- This study is grounded in constructivist learning theory, which asserts that learners construct knowledge through engagement with real-world experiences.
- The study followed the six (6) steps of thematic analysis by Braun and Clarke (2006).
- From a pragmatic perspective, our study asserts that constructivist learning theory holds significant potential in redefining assessments within an AI-infused learning environment.
- The initial search across three databases, Scopus (20), IEEE Xplore (300), and ScienceDirect (65), yielded a total of 385 records.
- To navigate these challenges, institutions should adopt a hybrid assessment model that integrates AI while preserving human oversight, ensuring fair and context-sensitive evaluations.
They conducted focus groups before Chatbot and after the intervention to evaluate changes in students’ views towards AI. However, both approaches fail to realistically address the problem and hinder meaningful learning about and with new technologies. This mistrust has also been revealed on a greater institutional level in work by Patricia Gasalla Canto and colleagues with students revealing institutional trust issues.
NCFDD’s Faculty Perspectives on AI survey report, based on responses from nearly 1,700 faculty members and academic administrators, found that 86.9% of respondents have already changed at least one aspect of their assessment practice. That question has always been central to assessment, but AI has changed some of the evidence faculty have traditionally relied on to answer it. At job sites, the paper notes, “assessment should focus on which skills workers will need to succeed in changing work environments” rather than a current role.
© 2026 Faculty Focus Higher Ed Teaching & Learning – All Rights Reserved.
- However, providing feedback is not the same as feedback being understood and used, and the value of GenAI feedback will depend on the feedback literacy of both educators and students (Carless & Winstone, 2023).
- Mills et al. (2025) developed a custom GPT to provide formative feedback to undergraduates, and Escalante et al. (2023) examined AI-generated feedback on the writing of English as a new language.
- This affordance aligns closely with the process-oriented assessment designs identified in RQ3, in which staged tasks, documentation, and reflection provide educators with insight into how learning develops.
- The fourth code, transparency of learning, captured the use of GenAI to make student achievement visible to educators in connection with learning objectives, allowing educators to see how students are progressing toward the intended goals of instruction.
- The final code, and one of the most frequent, was the use of GenAI to provide feedback.
- The studies in this review indicate that GenAI can address this bottleneck by providing immediate, personalized feedback at scale.
A student learning to code may encounter different expectations at the beginning of a sequence than in an advanced course where AI-supported development tools are part of professional practice. Students might evaluate an AI-generated response, identify weaknesses in its reasoning, verify its claims, or improve on its analysis. That makes the educational purpose of an assignment an increasingly important starting point. For example, 85.5% of humanities faculty, 78.9% of social sciences faculty, 78.4% of STEM faculty, and 67.1% of faculty in professional fields say AI makes it harder to assess what students actually know. The report shows substantial disciplinary differences in how faculty are experiencing AI, but concern about student learning crosses those boundaries. That does not necessarily make the Generative artificial intelligence assignment itself obsolete, but it can change the question faculty need the assignment to answer.
Trained to stop learning: How students are experiencing assessment and learning in an age of AI – Wonkhe
Trained to stop learning: How students are experiencing assessment and learning in an age of AI.
Posted: Mon, 23 Mar 2026 07:00:00 GMT source
- Students’ output in response to these tests and assignments can be generated by AI, thus undermining their validity, as they do not test what they should be testing–students’ learning.
- Additionally, AI can provide personalised feedback, guiding students towards ethical writing practices and self-regulated learning .
- We also examine potential strategies to uphold academic integrity and the credibility of assessments for academic evaluations.
- This makes it imperative for educators to become more skillful in how they assess student learning.
- This is the first in a 5-part series about the impact of artificial intelligence on education and research, exploring its potential applications and addressing issues of concern.
- Therefore, establishing clear boundaries and implementing robust protective measures is essential to maintaining the credibility of academic evaluations.
- As a result, educators must adapt assessment practices that can inform them about their students’ learning and help them make the necessary decisions related to their teaching practices.
These reviews provide important contextual understanding of the broader GenAI landscape in HE. While these reviews provide important foundational understanding of AI applications in education, assessment represented only one component within a much broader examination of AI in education. Research suggests that GenAI may support personalized learning, provide adaptive support, and enhance student engagement when integrated thoughtfully into teaching and learning processes (Francis et al., 2025). Since the release of ChatGPT, GenAI technologies such as Claude, Gemini, Copilot, and AI-integrated platforms have rapidly expanded across HE contexts (Wilson, 2025). These developments created conditions for the rapid integration of GenAI into HE assessment environments, necessitating the need https://aicurated.com/ for the development of faculty knowledge and skill in the integration of GenAI in assessment practices. Digital technologies have progressively reshaped assessment through online testing systems, automated feedback, learning analytics, and e-portfolios (Selwyn, 2022).
- Learning analytics dashboards, which featured prominently in earlier AI in education research as the means by which AI made student learning visible to educators (Crompton & Burke, 2023), were absent from the studies in this review.
- This may indicate that the conversational paradigm of GenAI is displacing dashboard-style analytics in educators’ assessment practice, or that the integration of GenAI with institutional analytics infrastructure has not yet been realized.
- Institutions should therefore pair clear policies on acceptable GenAI use with sustained professional learning that builds these capacities, rather than relying on integrity rules alone.
- We would like to thank Christine Nickel for supporting in the development of the figures in this article.
- This represents a democratization of AI in education affordances, placing assessment design, personalization, and evaluation support directly in the hands of faculty.
- For institutional leaders and policymakers, these findings indicate that faculty development is central to an effective response to GenAI.
- What distinguishes the present findings is access and expanded capabilities.
As AI changes how students learn, how teachers teach, and what learners need to know, the group aimed to reimagine how assessment can support equity, innovation, and continuous improvement across K–12, higher education, the workforce, and research. This page is equipped with both a Masterclass video for you to watch and also an instructional guide that provides tips & tricks for prompt writing. The instructor assumes the role of a facilitator and guides students by monitoring progress and providing thinking prompts.
Assessment is also increasingly expected to foster evaluative judgment and self-regulated learning capabilities that extend beyond university study (Tai et al., 2018). Discover the latest articles, books and news in related subjects, suggested using machine learning. Their experiences also show why institutions need to provide the Transformer (deep learning architecture) time, resources, and guidance that make this work sustainable. For departments and institutions, supporting this work means recognizing assessment redesign as substantive faculty work. “I’ve had to redesign almost every assignment and assessment so it can be completed and evaluated in the context of an AI environment. That nuance matters when faculty are establishing expectations for individual assignments.
Leave A Comment